Subsurface Ledger Tap Water & Groundwater Atlas
Research Briefing 01 ยท Nationwide UCMR 5 PFAS Audit

EPA UCMR 5 PFAS Drinking Water Detections: Public Water Systems Exceeding Federal PFOA & PFOS MCL Thresholds

By Meru AI Published 6 min read Publication 3519f42f4cbb6094cdb2

Across 1,991,977 analytical laboratory rows published in the US Environmental Protection Agency Fifth Unregulated Contaminant Monitoring Rule (UCMR 5, 2023 to 2025), 1,734 of 10,313 tested public water systems (16.8%) recorded at least one sample strictly above April 2024 EPA Maximum Contaminant Levels, led by PFOS (1,326 utilities) and PFOA (1,276 utilities).

Unit Normalization: Why Raw EPA UCMR 5 Microgram Tables Mislead Casual Audits

Every quantitative audit of nationwide per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) in municipal tap water begins with a deceptive unit boundary inside the raw federal archive (UCMR5_All.txt). EPA publishes AnalyticalResultValue in micrograms per liter (ug/L, parts per billion), whereas the legally enforceable National Primary Drinking Water Regulation finalized in April 2024 establishes Maximum Contaminant Levels (MCLs) in nanograms per liter (ng/L, parts per trillion): 4.0 ng/L for PFOA and PFOS, and 10.0 ng/L individually for PFHxS, PFNA, and HFPO-DA (GenX chemicals).

In the Subsurface Ledger reconciliation pipeline (publication 3519f42f4cbb6094cdb2), all 38,562 quantified PFAS detections across the 29 monitored PFAS analytes are deterministically scaled by x1,000 from ug/L to ng/L, while the 18,939 quantified Lithium observations remain in ug/L against EPA's 10.0 ug/L Health Reference Level (HRL). Equally important, 1,934,476 analytical rows (97.1% of the entire federal release) carry AnalyticalResultsSign = '<', indicating concentration below the laboratory Minimum Reporting Level (<MRL). Treating <MRL records as numeric zeros understates analytical uncertainty; substituting the MRL itself fabricates false exceedances because the 4.0 ng/L PFOA and PFOS MRL sits squarely on the 4.0 ng/L MCL threshold.

Table 1. Nationwide EPA UCMR 5 Compound Occurrence & MCL Benchmark Reconciliation (2023 to 2025)
Compound Unit Lab MRL EPA Benchmark Total Samples Quantified Detects PWS w/ Detect PWS > MCL Peak Value
PFOS ng/L 4.0 4.0 66,357 4,468 1,352 1,326 490.0
PFOA ng/L 4.0 4.0 66,358 4,354 1,305 1,276 235.0
PFHxS ng/L 3.0 10.0 66,346 3,231 1,037 172 250.2
PFNA ng/L 4.0 10.0 66,358 176 83 21 99.8
HFPO-DA ng/L 5.0 10.0 66,361 128 48 17 170.0
Lithium ug/L 9.0 10.0 66,675 18,939 3,773 0 960.0
PFPeA ng/L 3.0 Unregulated 66,342 7,040 2,066 0 358.0
PFBA ng/L 5.0 Unregulated 66,355 5,463 1,935 0 1,700.0
PFHxA ng/L 3.0 Unregulated 66,356 6,060 1,807 0 260.0
PFBS ng/L 3.0 2,000.0 66,354 5,690 1,707 0 290.0

Compound Hierarchy: Long-Chain Legacy Surfactants vs. Short-Chain Replacements

When evaluated strictly above numeric MCL benchmarks, legacy eight-carbon fluorosurfactants dominate compliance exposure, yet short-chain carboxylic replacements account for the widest geographic footprint. Across 10,313 UCMR 5 utilities, 3,595 systems (34.9%) reported at least one quantified PFAS detection above laboratory MRL, and 1,734 systems recorded at least one sample exceeding an individual federal PFAS MCL across 9,035 exceedance samples (9,333 samples when including exact 4.0 ng/L and 10.0 ng/L boundary ties).

Short-Chain Mobility in Alluvial Aquifers

Notice the divergence in Table 1 between detection breadth and regulatory exceedance counts. Perfluoropentanoic acid (PFPeA) appears in 2,066 public water systems (7,040 quantified samples), perfluorobutanoic acid (PFBA) in 1,935 systems (peaking at 1,700.0 ng/L), perfluorohexanoic acid (PFHxA) in 1,807 systems, and perfluorobutanesulfonic acid (PFBS) in 1,707 systems. Because PFPeA, PFBA, and PFHxA lack standalone individual numeric MCLs in the April 2024 rule, and PFBS carries a 2,000.0 ng/L Health-Based Water Concentration component inside the Hazard Index mixture formula, utilities with widespread short-chain detections can look compliant on single-analyte PFOA/PFOS screens while still requiring granular activated carbon (GAC) or ion-exchange breakthroughs to be engineered for faster-eluting four- and five-carbon chains.

High-Frequency Exceedance Systems Across Alluvial & Industrial Corridors

Among individual water utilities, high exceedance counts reflect both underlying aquifer plume persistence and large multi-well entry-point networks where dozens of groundwater treatment plants are sampled quarterly. In California alone, 166 of 707 UCMR 5-tested utilities (23.5%) recorded at least one sample above federal PFAS MCLs.

Table 2. Public Water Systems with Highest Sample Counts Above Federal PFAS MCLs in Reconciled Preview
PWSID Water System Name State UCMR 5 Samples Quantified Detects Samples > MCL Peak PFOA (ng/L) Peak PFOS (ng/L)
CA1010007 CITY OF FRESNO CA 10,151 213 85 16.0 30.0
NC0326127 BROOKWOOD COMM WTR SYSTEM NC 1,260 216 84 27.5 33.3
GU0000006 GWA NORTHERN WATER SYSTEM GU 3,630 331 64 18.3 135.0
NJ0251001 RIDGEWOOD WATER NJ 1,140 257 62 31.4 13.8
AZ0404032 PAYSON TOWN OF AZ 1,560 242 56 40.9 42.2
NC0326332 CLIFFDALE WEST NC 1,620 179 55 16.3 19.5
PA1090089 NORTHAMPTON BUCKS CO MUN AUTH PA 1,020 172 51 19.6 23.0
PA1460073 AQUA PA MAIN SYSTEM PA 1,500 227 51 12.6 9.2

Capital Planning Implications for Municipal Utilities & Bond Analysts

For water-resources engineers, municipal credit analysts, and ratepayer advocates, raw peak concentration tells only half the operational story. Consider CA1010007 (City of Fresno), which spans 10,151 UCMR 5 analytical rows across an extensive alluvial wellfield in the Kings Subbasin (5-022.08): 9,938 rows are clean <MRL non-detects, while 85 samples exceed federal PFAS limits with peak PFOS at 30.0 ng/L and PFOA at 16.0 ng/L. Contrast that multi-well blending and wellhead-treatment profile against smaller single-aquifer systems in industrial fluorochemical corridors such as NC0326127 (Brookwood Community Water System in North Carolina's Cape Fear watershed, 84 exceedances across a smaller sampling base) or NJ0251001 (Ridgewood Water in northern New Jersey, 62 exceedances, peak PFOA 31.4 ng/L).

Where utilities rely on blended groundwater and surface-water turnouts (GW/SW), seasonal surface-water curtailments during drought years force operators back onto standby groundwater wells. Cross-referencing EPA UCMR 5 entry-point detections with California SGMA borehole screen depths and SWRCB SAFER co-contaminant violations reveals whether GAC, anion-exchange resin, or reverse-osmosis capital expenditure must simultaneously remove nitrate, arsenic, or 1,2,3-trichloropropane (1,2,3-TCP) that compete for adsorption sites or foul membranes.

Methodology & Analytical Scope Limitations

EPA UCMR 5 mandates monitoring for all public water systems serving >= 3,300 residents plus a statistically selected sample of 800 smaller systems nationwide. Consequently, single-sample or peak UCMR 5 exceedances documented here are point-in-time entry-point analytical measurements rather than four-quarter running annual averages (RAA), which govern formal Safe Drinking Water Act MCL compliance starting in 2029. Furthermore, utilities serving fewer than 3,300 people omitted from UCMR 5 must never be interpreted as PFAS-free; see our Data Reconciliation Methodology and interactive Subsurface Ledger Explorer to inspect system-specific sampling coverage.